« Oh, the Blasphemy...And the Poor Grammar | Main | The Friday Random Ten. Again. »

A Stab at That Guilt Prompt

In high school I convinced myself that I had AIDS.  Mind you, there wasn't a terribly rational basis for that thought but, nonetheless, I was absolutely certain of my disease.  I was so sure that getting a test would only confirm the inevitable.  I never went for one until years later.

People who know me now know that I'm somewhat of a hypocondriac, but I find it curious that my neuroses began around the time that I started to more actively explore my sexuality.  Ever since I can remember, there's been this lingering belief (and, granted, it's becoming less prevalent as I've been working to grow and evolve) that because I'm not a "good person," I deserve some cruel fate.

The fact that I had done something through which, theoretically, I could have contracted HIV was enough to convince me that I was sick (I may have experimented some in my adolesence, but I was far from promiscuous).  Obviously there was a larger issue at hand: my own guilt.

While I do find it interesting that said guilt first manifested itself in regards to sexuality, I think that was merely its vehicle of choice at the time.  Growing up my parents did a decent good job of stifling my need to grow and explore due, predominantly, to their own fears.  My mother, in particular, was very anxious.  Her need to be in control and my need to become who I was trying to become often butted heads and, as a result, I experienced a bit of an unpleasant duality.  On the one hand I would revel in my newfound independence, but then I would seemingly revert to feeling badly because I had "upset" her on some level.

The way I see it, my guilt wasn't about sexuality per se, but about my own seeming inability to live fully into all aspects of my humanity without inspring the displeasure of my parents.  As I write this now, I'm remembering a discussion we had in my honors class about One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest and how, in essence, we decided that to repress one's sexuality was to repress one's humanity on some level.

Growing up I unfortunately learned to repress a number of aspects of my humanity when they weren't "acceptable."  I "punished" myself (diseases were just one way!).  I buried feelings.  I learned to live in my head.  I deferred to my intellect.

Of course this all came at a price, as my guilt has been a somewhat debilitating force.  To that end, it has made me overly sensitive to the cues of others; I absolutely obsess when there are implications of wrongdoing, regardless of how irrational they may be.  The recent "dirty book" debacle is a perfect example.  Certainly I know intellectually that I am not immoral and that I possess integrity as a teacher.  But yet, I still can't help to shake the feeling that I've done something "wrong," simply because this woman pointed a finger in my direction.

There are times when guilt has immobilized me; I've become so obsessed with the idea of doing/saying/choosing the "wrong thing," that I've given in to inactivity (remember that post about ambivalence a while back?!).  Of course a byproduct of not only guilt, but also its manifestations, has been some degree of low self-esteem.

Granted all of this insight isn't worth a damn thing if I don't do something with it.  And I'm working.  Hard.  I wish it were as easy as casting guilt aside so that "the ants might feast on it" (I love it, KJ), but the truth is that believing I'm a good person is harder than I'd like it to be sometimes.

Oh, and in case you're wondering, I don't have AIDS.  And, thankfully, I don't feel too bad saying so these days. 
Posted on Monday, June 19, 2006 at 10:14AM by Registered CommenterPopscholar in | Comments6 Comments

Reader Comments (6)

a--i love this post and your vulnerable honesty, which is a relief to the rest of us, since we all know exactly precisely what you are saying, since we've all been there. ! i'm always wondering how other people see me and judge me and i can trace it right back to my mother's concern with the neighbors and relatives. it was hard to know what i actually felt since it was always screened though the opinion of others.

"Her need to be in control and my need to become who I was trying to become often butted heads and, as a result, I experienced a bit of an unpleasant duality."

this is so insightful. what is now ypersensitivity will get less complicated as you learn and leave you with the great sensitivity you have.

i really enjoyed this a, so forget about apron wringing..!

kj
June 19, 2006 | Unregistered Commenterkj
I feel you.

As much as I say I want to hear honest feedback about ... whatever... teaching, writing, etc., I don't handle criticism all that well.

A cutting comment from an administrator, a colleague, a student... will... well, it will no longer put me in a depression, but it will throw me for a loop and keep me in a funk for a while. Even if -- maybe especially if -- it's completely invalid.
June 19, 2006 | Unregistered CommenterTom Kim
Thanks, kj. It definitely feels vulnerable and honest -- in fact, I feel kind of naked right now. I keep having this urge to run and grab a metaphorical towel!

Tom -- I am exactly the same way. For all of my seeming togetherness on the surface, I'm actually super-sensitive and criticism in any form really pulls for all of that doubt that creeps in from time to time...

BTW... It was great to meet and chat on Saturday!
June 19, 2006 | Unregistered CommenterPopscholar
Striking the balance between being the filial child yet being independent and living your life is the life long struggle. A constant.

I have found solace in the philosophy/arms of an Eastern man. His acceptance from my body to my family has allowed me to shrug off the mantel that I am not good enough. I am not a good Mormon anymore and part of me mourns that, but I have never been happier in my life.
June 20, 2006 | Unregistered Commentersdg
S -- I, too, have a ton of help and support when it comes to working to shrug off the "I'm not a good person" feeling (from G to my stellar therapist to friends and even family), but it's deeply-rooted and therefore it's taking some definite time and effort. I'm learning to value the journey in the process.
June 20, 2006 | Registered CommenterPopscholar
a--your honesty and ability to articulate your feelings and the source of those feelings is incredible. i tend to become a ball of nonsense when i try to do the same.

you should be damn proud of yourself for all the work you have done and continue to do. this post is a part of it.
June 20, 2006 | Unregistered Commenterkrizmic

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.